Foster Care Associated With Improved Growth, Intelligence Compared With Orphanage Care
April 12, 2010
April 12, 2010
Article Date: 07 Apr 2010 – 9:00 PDT
Socially deprived children removed from orphanages and placed in foster care appear to experience gains in growth and intelligence, catching up to their non-institutionalized peers on many measures, according to a report posted online today that will appear in the June print issue of Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, one of the JAMA/Archives journals.
Social deprivation-a lack of access to social and material resources-is known to be associated with a syndrome of poor growth in children, according to background information in the article. “Several subtypes have been described, though all share two characteristics: otherwise unexplained growth failure occurring in association with socially stressful conditions and significant catch-up when a child’s caregiving environment improves,” the authors write.
Dana E. Johnson, M.D., Ph.D., of University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, and colleagues studied 136 healthy institutionalized infants (average age 21 months) from six orphanages in Bucharest, Romania. Of these, half were randomly assigned to remain in their facilities and half were assigned to a foster care program. Their growth rates and measures of intelligence over time were assessed and they were compared with each other and with a group of 72 never-institutionalized children at 30, 42 and 54 months of age. Caregiving environments were evaluated by analyzing and coding 90-minute videotapes of the children interacting with their preferred caregivers.
At the beginning of the study, institutionalized children displayed compromised growth and development, with more severe deficits among those who were born weighing less than 2,500 grams (approximately 5.5 pounds). Children assigned to foster care showed rapid increases in height and weight (but not head circumference), so that by 12 months 100 percent of them were in the normal range for height, 90 percent were in the normal range for weight and 94 percent were in the normal range of weight for height.
Caregiving quality was a predictor of this catch-up growth. “Components of the caregiving-quality score positively correlated with catch-up included sensitivity (child-centered, contingent responses) and positive regard for the child (acceptance, respect and warmth, including expressions of physical affection),” the authors write.
Children whose height caught up to normal levels also appeared to improve their cognitive (thinking, learning and memory) abilities. “Each incremental increase of one in standardized height scores between baseline and 42 months was associated with a mean [average] increase of 12.6 points in verbal IQ,” the authors write.
“The significance of these findings extends beyond the millions of children worldwide within institutional or conventional foster care to the hundreds of millions of impoverished children who have stunted growth and/or do not meet their developmental potential and are living within families,” the authors conclude. “Psychosocial deprivation within any caregiving environment during early life is as detrimental as malnutrition and must be viewed with as much concern as any severely debilitating childhood disease.”
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2010;164:(doi:10.1001/archpediatrics.2010.56).
Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine